| UNK |  Bob Tice | Guard | June 17, 1916 | Lexington, KY (Henry Clay) | 5-11 | - |
| UNK | Walter Hatcher | Forward | June 28, 1916 | Pikeville, KY | 5-9 | 148 |
| 3 |  Robert Strohm | | March 16, 1916 | Chicago, IL | 6-2 | - |
| 3 |  Bernard Opper | Guard | September 1, 1915 | New York, NY (Morris High) | 5'10" | 185 |
| 5 |  John McIntosh | Forward | October 26, 1913 | Hazard, KY | - | - |
| 6 |  Warfield Donohue | Guard | May 28, 1915 | Louisville, KY (St. Xavier) | 6'2" | - |
| 9 |  Charles Combs | Guard | November 11, 1914 | Happy, KY (Berea Academy) | 5'11" | 160 |
| 10 |  Elmo Head | Forward | September 15, 1917 | Shelbyville, KY | 5'10" | 146 |
| 13 |  Homer Thompson | Center | January 18, 1916 | Jeffersonville, IN (High) | 6'4" | 215 |
| 13 |  Robert Davis | Center | May 5, 1914 | Dayton, KY (High) | 6'0" | 170 |
| 13 |  Robert Davis | Center | May 5, 1914 | Dayton, KY (High) | 6-0 | 170 |
| 14 |  Ralph Carlisle | Forward | January 26, 1915 | Lawrenceburg, KY [Kavanaugh School, Lawrenceburg, KY] | 6'2" | - |
| 14 |  Joseph Hagan | Forward | July 12, 1913 | Louisville, KY (Male & St. Xavier) | 6'2" | - |
| 15 |  J. Rice Walker | Center-Forward | October 18, 1917 | Lexington, KY (Henry Clay) | 6'3" | 190 |
| 24 |  James Goforth | Guard | October 19, 1913 | Louisville, KY (Male) | 6'0" | 200 |
| 26 |  Walter Hodge | Forward | September 18, 1915 | Paris, KY (High) | 6'3" | 176 |
| 27 |  Fred Curtis | Forward | February 13, 1915 | Nashville, TN (East) | 6'2" | 169 |
